• For staff
  • For Staff
  • Services A-Z
  • Student Education Service
  • For students
  • Portal
  • Mobile app
  • For Students
  • Faculties
  • Faculty of Arts, Humanities and Cultures
  • Faculty of Biological Sciences
  • Faculty of Business
  • Faculty of Engineering and Physical Sciences
  • Faculty of Environment
  • Faculty of Medicine and Health
  • Faculty of Social Sciences
  • Lifelong Learning Centre
  • Language Centre
  • Other
  • Staff A-Z
  • Campus map
  • Jobs
  • Alumni
  • Contacts
  • Library
  • IT
  • VideoLeeds
  • Leeds University Union
  • Follow us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Medium
  • Weibo
  • The Conversation
  • RSS news feed
University of Leeds logo
Centre for African Studies (LUCAS)
  • Home
  • About
  • People
  • Schools Project
  • Bulletin
  • Study Africa
  • YASN
  • News
  • Events
  • Resources
  • Home
  • Leeds African Studies Bulletin
  • Leeds African Studies Bulletin No. 73 (2011/12)
  • Article

In this Issue

Analysing Africa

  • The Question of Insecurity in the Southern Cameroons Reunification Debate - Joseph Nfi

Reading Africa

  • Pleasure, Autonomy and the Myth of the Untouchable Body in Bessie Head’s Maru - Natasha Lloyd-Owen
  • Review of Milk and Peace, Drought and War: Somali Culture, Society and Politics - Lionel Cliffe
  • Review of Land, Memory, Reconstruction, and Justice/ Making History in Mugabe’s Zimbabwe - Lionel Cliffe
  • Review of And Crocodiles Are Hungry At Night. A Memoir/ J P Clark. A Voyage / The Dennis Brutus Tapes. Essays at Autobiography - Martin Banham
  • Review of Mauritania: The Struggle for Democracy - Hannah Cross
  • Review of Circular Migration in Zimbabwe and Contemporary Sub-Saharan Africa - Hannah Cross
  • Review of Africa’s Informal Workers: Collective Agency, Alliances and Transitional Organizing in Urban Africa - Anne Tallontire
  • Review of The African Diaspora and the Disciplines - Osita Okagbue
  • Review of Ethiopia: The Last two Frontiers - Jane Plastow
  • Review of Oil and Insurgency in the Niger Delta: Managing the Complex Politics of Petro-Violence - James Van Alstine
  • Review of Dhow Cultures of the Indian Ocean: Cosmopolitanism, Commerce and Islam - Arthur Rose
  • Review of Peace versus Justice? The Dilemma of Transitional Justice in Africa - Kevin Ward
  • Review of Film in African Literature Today 28 - David Kerr
  • Review of Gendering the African Diaspora: Women, Culture, and Historical Change in the Caribbean and Nigerian Hinterland - Karen Cereso
  • Review of Nigeria, Nationalism, and Writing History - Vincent Hiribarren
  • Review of Stirring the Pot: A History of African Cuisine - Lynette Hunter
  • Review of Chocolate Nations: Living and Dying for Cocoa in West Africa - James Gibbs

Remembering Africa

  • In memory of Ulli Beier - Eckhard Breitinger
  • Chinua Achebe at Leeds: When the Great Share the Good - Brendon Nicholls

Leeds African Studies Bulletin No. 73 (2011/12) Friday 19 August 2011

Review of Peace versus Justice? The Dilemma of Transitional Justice in Africa

By Kevin Ward (University of Leeds)

Abstract

 

  • Article keywords:
  • Central African Republic
  • Chandra Lekha Sriram
  • Charles Taylor
  • Congo
  • Joseph Kony
  • Kevin Ward
  • Mozambique
  • Sierra Leone
  • South Africa
  • Suren Pillay
  • Truth and Reconciliation Commission
  • Uganda

Peace versus Justice? The Dilemma of Transitional Justice in Africa. Chandra Lekha Sriram and Suren Pillay (eds). University of KwaZulu-Natal Press, Scottsville (South Africa), 2009. Pp. xiii+373. ISBN. 978 1 84701 021 6 (pb). £19.99.

The book examines the various kinds of institutions set up in the aftermath of conflicts in Africa to deal with the aftermath of conflict: the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) of South Africa provided the inspiration for other similar commissions. But there are have also been other institutional attempts to enable countries to negotiate the transition to democratic and peaceful regimes, including war crime tribunals, indigenous forms of justice and reconciliation, and, more recently, the intervention of the International Criminal Court. The contributors are often ‘insiders’ who have been officially involved in the processes; many are academics, mostly from within Africa itself. Some are both insiders and academics. All agree that ‘Peace versus Justice’ is a false dichotomy. There are no ideal solutions in the field of  transitional justice; there are always tensions between the desire and need to prosecute the perpetrators of crimes so that full accountability is achieved, and the reality that, in order to end conflict, there will need to be multiple  compromises in which justice can only be imperfectly implemented. By and large the South African TRC is  regarded by the contributors to have been a surprising success, in providing evidence of  past wrongs, in engaging in a public debate in which victims could tell their story and perpetrators revealed information which otherwise would not have been unearthed. But the contributors are also well aware of the limitations of the TRC: the failure to persuade white South Africans to confront the reality of the regime from which they benefited for so long; the tendency to concentrate on individual acts of inhumanity such as torture and illegal killings, rather than to confront the  evils of apartheid in its systematic racial stigmatisation and economic disempowerment (as Soyinke and Mamdani have complained).

In comparison the implementation of transitional justice in Sierra Leone has been much more problematic and the positive results less clear. Partly this is to do with the creation of two parallels institutions: a Sierra Leone TRC set up by the Lomé Accord and subsequently a Special Court under which perpetrators could be tried. The TRC never achieved the level of popular acceptance accorded to the South African TRC, and was involved in a dispute over whether Chief Samuel Norman, already indicted before the court, should testify before the TRC. Norman himself, whatever his involvement in war crimes, remained a popular figure  within Sierra Leone, and his prosecution was a cause of further tensions rather than healing of divisions. The circumstances of Charles Taylor’s arrest and the transfer of his trial to the Hague also did little to endear Sierra Leonians to the institutions set up to secure transitional justice. On the other hand, the seriousness with which the Sierra Leone institutions have regarded violence against women and children, has been seen as admirable. In Rwanda there have been  different tensions:  between the international court set up in Arusha, outside the control of  Rwandan authorities; and the local gacaca courts set up later within Rwanda itself, which for different reasons, have also been criticised, not least for prolonging stereotypes of ‘Tutsi’ as only victims, and ‘Hutu’ as only perpetrators.

Two of the most interesting articles in the book concern Mozambique, which has had neither truth commission nor court. Despite this, Mozambique has been, in some ways, a model of reconciliation. Victor Igreja is critical of the decision in the peace negotiations to employ a strategy of ‘amnesia and impunity’. But he has shown how traditional (or adaptations of traditional) rites of healing and cleansing have played an important part in societies learning to cope with the past. The magamba spirits of fallen soldiers are invoked in acts of disclosure and reparation, which can be seen as having therapeutic implications for post-conflict society.

The final section looks at the relatively recently created International Criminal Court, and its operation in relation to the indictment of Joseph Kony of the Lord’s Resistance Army (active in Uganda, and subsequently in the Congo and Central African Republic). This is seen as problematic as potentially it obstructs actually coming to a peace accord, and is regarded with active suspicion by local people who are most concerned to get peace.

This is a long book, with 16 contributors. Too long – there is a considerable amount of repetition of basic facts. The extent to which the contributors explore methodological and conceptual issues, or provide genuinely new information about the operation of transitional justice in a particular country, varies greatly. The chapter on Mozambique by Igreja is a model of conceptual clarity and fascinating details in this regard. Some of the others tread well worn paths in a rather desultory way. With the exception of Igreja, this book is mainly useful in providing a general discourse on the problem of transitional justice in Africa as a whole, rather than in any in-depth consideration of individual cases. 

[Published in Leeds African Studies Bulletin 73 (December 2011), pp. 81-83]

  • Article Categories:
  • Reading Africa
  • © 2021 University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT
  • Terms and conditions
  • Copyright
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy and Cookies
  • Freedom of Information
  • Blog