• For staff
  • For Staff
  • Services A-Z
  • Student Education Service
  • For students
  • Portal
  • Mobile app
  • For Students
  • Faculties
  • Faculty of Arts, Humanities and Cultures
  • Faculty of Biological Sciences
  • Faculty of Business
  • Faculty of Engineering and Physical Sciences
  • Faculty of Environment
  • Faculty of Medicine and Health
  • Faculty of Social Sciences
  • Lifelong Learning Centre
  • Language Centre
  • Other
  • Staff A-Z
  • Campus map
  • Jobs
  • Alumni
  • Contacts
  • Library
  • IT
  • VideoLeeds
  • Leeds University Union
  • Follow us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Medium
  • Weibo
  • The Conversation
  • RSS news feed
University of Leeds logo
Centre for African Studies (LUCAS)
  • Home
  • About
  • People
  • Schools Project
  • Bulletin
  • Study Africa
  • YASN
  • News
  • Events
  • Resources
  • Home
  • Leeds African Studies Bulletin
  • Leeds African Studies Bulletin No. 69 (2007/08)
  • Article

In this Issue

Analysing Africa

  • Ibadan 1960 - Martin Banham
  • The LUCAS Schools' Global Citizenship Project - Jane Plastow
  • Supernumeraries of the Human Race? Reflections on the African 'holocaust' - Morris Szeftel

Reading Africa

  • Review of African Theatre and Performances - Martin Banham
  • Review of Ngoma: Approaches to Arts Education in Southern Africa - Martin Banham
  • Review of Various titles from Bayreuth African Studies - Martin Banham
  • Review of Black Star / The African Slave Trade - Martin Banham
  • Review of Ngugi wa Thiong’o Speaks: Interviews with the Kenyan Writer - Martin Banham
  • Review of State of Violence: Politics, Youth and Memory in Contemporary Africa - Michael Etherton
  • Review of African Theatre: Youth - Tim Prentki
  • Review of Aawambo Kingdoms: History and Cultural Change - Will Jackson
  • Review of Public and Private Universities in Kenya / Gender in the Making of the Nigerian University System / Change and Transformation in Ghana's Publicly Funded University - James Gibbs
  • Review of Beautiful Ugly: African and Diaspora Aesthetics - Will Rea
  • Review of Far in the Waste Sudan: On Assignment in Africa - Michael Medley
  • Review of Democratic Reform in Africa: Its Impact on Governance and Poverty Alleviation - Michael Medley
  • Review of Native Sons: West African Veterans and France in the Twentieth Century - Ineke van Kessel
  • Review of Globalisation and Race: Transformations in the Cultural Production of Blackness - Dr. Olasunkanmi Sholarin
  • Review of Writing Madness: Borderlines of the body in African literature - Jane Plastow
  • Review of Journey of Song: Public Life and Morality in Cameroon - Bill Jong-Ebot

Leeds African Studies Bulletin No. 69 (2007/08) Friday 29 June 2007

Review of Beautiful Ugly: African and Diaspora Aesthetics

By Will Rea (University of Leeds)

Abstract

 

  • Article keywords:
  • art
  • Sarah Nuttall
  • Will Rea

Beautiful Ugly: African and Diaspora Aesthetics. Ed. Sarah Nuttall, Duke University Press in conjunction with the Prince Claus Fund, Durham and London, 2006. Pp 416, 126 illustrations £ 17.99

This is a beautiful book – that is, the production values given to the publication by Duke University Press and no doubt supported by the Prince Claus Fund are wonderful, beautiful even. The essays are supported by the kind of colour reproduction that it is rare to find even in the museum catalogues of blockbuster exhibitions. The essays are even colour highlighted, and there is an over all feel to the book of sumptuous quality. This is a book destined for bookshops that exist as the essential adjunct of the modern art gallery. As such it is no doubt going to picked up and read by a metropolitan art elite of the type well versed in ‘post modern / postcolonial / deconstructive / discourse analysis’; the question though is whether the book doesn’t simply add more exotica for the art hungry savages of the west desperately seeking Africa?

Beautiful Ugly is both a timely book and a book of its time. It is an irritating book as well as one that contains some surprises and some genuine importance. Beautiful Ugly indeed. In general it is a book that purports to explore the idea of beauty and/or ugliness and/or the sublime within African discourses of the aesthetic or perhaps, more broadly, taste. It is however, firmly orientated toward investigating the expression of that beauty /taste within the (what is becoming something of a cliché) contemporary African and African diaspora situation. Through these essays, some of which have been previously published, but most seemingly written for this volume, the authors track something that might be called beauty or be called the aesthetic through a series of different situations, idioms and places that all in some way relate to Africa.

Immediately the title starts flagging up the habitual warning signs that accompany any discussion of ‘African’ aesthetics. One does not have to have read Barry Hallen’s (1979) critique of Robert Farris Thompson’s categories of Yoruba aesthetics to realise that this is fraught and dangerous territory, intertwined in the politics of identity and the relationships that inhere between categories of taste and judgement found in the West and those found in African societies. Here is one of the irritating things. There is a long and complicated history of thought behind the idea of the aesthetic as it appears as a philosophical concept in African societies but this book makes little reference to these debates. Rather it firmly sets out in search of an aesthetic within the contemporary African situation. So, despite Gikandi’s and Mbembe’s opening pieces, I am not sure upon what philosophical grounds the book is standing. Maybe this is an unjustified criticism, perhaps the book doesn’t pretend to a ‘philosophy’, it is after all an art book and perhaps its intention is no more than to be illustrative of a diverse set of practices loosely organised around the theme of beauty / ugliness within some undefined contemporary historical period. The problem with this is that then the book potentially becomes no more than a type of modernist connoisseurship, collecting cultures where they conjoin to art. And this book clearly attends to more than this. Yet placing together a set of disparate, albeit desperately elegant papers, under the rubric of (an) African beauty (however that is figured) gives the impression of a metaphysical object that is universally applicable. We are back with Picasso and his sense of a universal African emotionalism (something well critiqued by Gikandi in the first essay of the book but something unfortunately other authors here seem incapable of avoiding). More than this, I suspect that what is really being discussed in many of the papers here is neither beauty nor ugliness, the sublime or the grotesque, but something that might be more recognisable as style.

What is good about this book is that it brings together some very interesting papers around the issue of art and politics and it clearly underlines Enwezor’s (2000) statement that some time ago contemporary art in Africa became imprisoned in theories of history, materiality and ethnicity. And that “What has been lost is a consideration of the form of the aesthetic that made up /makes up the experience of art within the post colony”. This book carries within it where it deals with the local situations a clear understanding of the need to engage with the forms of contemporary aesthetic production as they develop within histories and ethnicities, but which are not subordinate to either. For this, and for Nuttal’s very clear introduction of the terms of the artistic debate about aesthetics (although, as I say, not the philosophical one), the book is a valuable resource, and one that if read carefully certainly enhances ways of thinking through some African relations to beauty in the world – savages notwithstanding.

[Published in Leeds African Studies Bulletin 69 (2007), pp. 82-83]

  • Article Categories:
  • Reading Africa
  • © 2021 University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT
  • Terms and conditions
  • Copyright
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy and Cookies
  • Freedom of Information
  • Blog